For years, I have watched the political pendulum swing –
Left – Right – Left
Conservative – Liberal – Conservative
Blue – Red – Blue
One side wins. The other side loses. And the game goes on.
From its beginnings, the U.S. political system took shape within patriarchal and Eurocentric frameworks that concentrated decision-making authority in the hands of white men. Its laws and institutions shape whose knowledge, interests, and worldviews influence the decisions governing our collective lives.
But with our recent blue wave election outcome, we now have many Native, Black, Hispanic, Muslim, and other folx marginalized by dominant groups, including openly gay and transgender folx, as well as large numbers of women, entering public office.
And this new wave gives me hope.
Cautionary hope.
I come away from this election with a long-standing desire for governance rooted in relational responsibility rather than domination. That desire shapes the hope I feel now.
I invite you onto a path of ideas that have shaped my understanding of power, privilege, and social change. We’ll look at how systems of domination persist even when the people in office change, consider some of the deeper stories and assumptions shaping Western institutions, and explore possibilities for organizing our collective lives differently before returning to this election.
I remember Mark Charles discussing the candidates from the two major parties at that time asking, (paraphrased from memory):
“How do you like your racism? Overt or covert?”
Mark Charles is a co-author, with Soong-Chan Rah, of Unsettling Truths: The Ongoing, Dehumanizing Legacy of the Doctrine of Discovery. He is also hosts the podcast My Second Cup of Coffee. Mark Charles ran as an Independent candidate for President of the United States in 2020. I’ll leave his analysis to him; folks can read and/or listen to his work if they choose.
With his comment in mind, my attention turns to theologian Walter Wink’s discussion on domination systems in his book The Powers that Be. I find myself rephrasing the question asked by Charles:
“How do you like your domination system? Out in the open, or hidden behind a curtain? As a smokescreen?”
Because changing who holds office doesn’t necessarily change how authority itself is organized or exercised.
Remember – the U.S. political system is divisive by design.
Majority rule.
Mob rule.
Us and them.
Us-against-them.
Winners and losers.
Conflict built into the system.
My mind also turns to the teachings of Barbara Alice Mann, author of Iroquoian Women: The Gantowisas. Mann identifies three metanarratives that have been influential in shaping Western worldviews and the institutions built within them: monotheism, sexism, and conflict. Metanarratives are overarching stories and assumptions that shape how people understand the world, their place in it, and their relationships with one another.
Monotheism – A blueprint of cosmic hierarchy, with its binary divisions of God and Satan, good versus evil, righteous and heretic
Sexism – A mandate to subdue and rule over women and Mother Earth, establishing hierarchical authority and central control.
Conflict – A worldview organized around rigid, unequal categories:
Us /Them
Righteous/Heretic
Man/Woman
Man/Nature
These narratives shape how difference is understood and how relationships are organized. They influence whose knowledge is valued, whose voices carry authority, and whose interests receive protection.
Yet other understandings of relationship and responsibility have continued across generations. Belonging, kinship, reciprocity, interdependence, and responsibilities extending across peoples, species, and generations are present in living communities and knowledge systems. What might we understand about collective life when these ways of knowing and relating have greater influence in shaping the institutions that govern us?
I see the metanarratives of hierarchy and conquest reflected in influential Western social theory traditions – interpretations of scientific knowledge that are often presented as objective (meaning without bias).
Consider how scientific evolutionary theory has sometimes been interpreted through the lens of perpetual competition and survival-of-the-fittest. Social Darwinism took these ideas, using them to further rationalize inequity, imperialism, and domination of people and planet.
Yet living systems offer us many ways of understanding how life persists and flourishes. Cooperation, symbiosis, mutualism, adaptation, and interdependence are woven throughout relationships among living beings. And I am leaning into the teachings of Robin Wall Kimmerer, author of Braiding Sweetgrass: Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge and the Knowledge of Plants, here.
An emphasis on competition as the defining force of life can obscure these relationships and the many ways living beings contribute to one another’s survival and well-being. What might we understand about our own collective lives when we give these types of relationships greater attention?
Speaking of the term objective, let’s look again at language as a shaper of perception.
Objects — the grammatical and conceptual positioning of the world as things.
Objective — the ideal of detached, impartial observation.
Objectification — the treatment of living beings as things to be observed, classified, possessed, managed, or used.
Here, we are seeing a connection between ways of knowing and ways of relating to the world.
Kimmerer draws attention to the grammar in language: nouns, the use of “it” and possessive pronouns. Language can shape how we perceive the world and our relationships with it.
Consider what happens when living beings are understood through a grammar of ownership and control. Land becomes property we can own, alter, mine. Water becomes a resource we can confine, control, dam, and hoard. Animals become livestock, commodities, groceries. Trees become timber, and we cut down entire forests and all the life there suffers.
And consider what can become possible when we begin with a grammar of animacy, recognizing living beings as presences, persons, and participants in the living world and as beings who have a right to be.
| Ownership | Animacy | |
|---|---|---|
| Primary categories | Possessor and possessed | Animate and inanimate beings |
| View of Nature | Objects, collections, resources | Persons, subjects, kin |
| Linguistic focus | Nouns, things, property, assets | Verbs, action, presence, being |
| Relationship | Dominion and control | Reciprocity and mutual responsibility |
These are more than differences in language. They reflect different ways of understanding our place in the world. A grammar of animacy invites us to notice agency, interdependence, reciprocity, cooperation, and mutual responsibility. It opens our understanding of participation in a living community that extends beyond human beings.
And I pause here, wondering what might our relationships and collective lives look like when we begin with these understandings?
Regarding mental categories, Silvia Federici, in Caliban and the Witch: Women, the Body and Primitive Accumulation, examines how Descartes’ mind-body dualism, the separation of mind and body, contributed to the development of capitalism and new forms of social and economic control.
My understanding of her analysis:
Separating mind from body helped establish a view of the body as something that could be disciplined, controlled, and made productive. Elevating rational thought above bodily experience positioned the mind as supervisor and the body as a machine for labor and production.
This way of thinking also contributed to the displacement and suppression of other ways of knowing and relating to the living world. Women’s healing knowledge, reproductive capacities, communal practices, and relationships with land became targets of expanding state, religious, and economic systems of control.
Federici connects the persecution of women during the so-called witch hunts to these broader transformations, including the privatization of communal lands and the restructuring of social and economic relationships. King James’s 1597 publication Daemonologie offers one historical example of the religious and political forces involved.
These transformations helped establish ways of organizing society in which bodies, labor, land, and knowledge could be controlled and made productive for the benefit of those accumulating wealth and power. Yet the knowledge and practices through which people have cared for one another, sustained community life, and maintained relationships with the living world have continued across generations.
A worldview organized around hierarchy, division, possession, and control doesn’t remain an abstract philosophy. It takes shape in our institutions, our laws, our economic arrangements, and our everyday relationships.
This is one way that structural violence operates.
Violence doesn’t always arrive as an act of physical aggression. It can be built into the ordinary ways a society distributes land, wealth, resources, opportunity, and decision-making power. It can be embedded in laws and institutional practices that systematically disadvantage some while protecting the interests of others.
Our legal system can enable and perpetuate these arrangements:
- Corporate laws that facilitate empire building.
- Anti-trust laws that go unenforced while corporate power continues to concentrate.
- Citizens United and the expanded role of corporate and wealthy interests in political spending.
Law provides a means through which societies establish responsibilities, recognize relationships, and determine how resources and decision-making authority are distributed.
Law can authorize the confiscation and expropriation of land, resources, and wealth. It can authorize the extraction of resources and labor, shape production and economic relationships, and protect the accumulation of surplus and profit in the hands of particular players.
Legalized – but perhaps not necessarily legitimate.
In some worldviews, the concentration of power and wealth is discouraged. Responsibilities to community, land, water, plant and animal kin, and future generations carry weight in decision making.
Whose worldview? Whose laws? Whose consent determines legitimacy? And from whose lands do these systems of authority originate?
These questions matter because different understandings of legitimacy can lead to very different ways of organizing collective life.
I have been thinking about the relationships through which political and economic power is organized and maintained. I see a broad complex of power involving political, legal, financial, military, industrial, technological, media, educational, and philanthropic institutions. These are not simply separate centers of authority that occasionally intersect. Power circulates through their relationships. They continually influence, support, constrain, and reproduce one another.
Dwight Eisenhower famously named the Military-Industrial Complex. I see it as part of a much longer history of relationships between commercial enterprises and political power, including charter companies of empire:
- Dutch East India Company.
- British East India Company.
- Hudson’s Bay Company, which ended its retail operations in 2025.
These charter companies were commercial enterprises to which nation-states granted extraordinary powers including territorial administration, military force, monopoly privileges, taxation, and governance. They weren’t simply businesses operating within an empire. They were also instruments through which empires extended their authority, controlled territories, and extracted wealth.
Relationships such as these continue to shape the institutions through which decisions are made, resources are distributed, and wealth is accumulated. Political decisions shape laws; laws influence financial arrangements; corporate interests influence political decisions; and media and educational institutions shape how people understand these arrangements.
Here I turn to physicist and philosopher Karen Barad and her concept of intra-action. Barad uses this concept to describe how boundaries, identities, and capacities emerge through relationships rather than existing independently beforehand.
I’m drawing on Barad’s concept and applying it to institutional power: considering how the globalized matrix of political power and privilege operates as a web of relationships through which institutions, interests, and forms of authority take shape and are continually reproduced across time and place.
So, what does all this have to do with an election?
Quite a lot, I think.
Changing who occupies positions of authority matters. People bring their unique experiences, and understandings of knowledge, relationships, and responsibility into the positions they hold.
They also bring relationships, histories, and priorities that may influence whose knowledge is considered, which issues receive attention, and how decisions are approached.
And this brings me back to why this particular election gives me hope.
Many Native American women were elected to office – in the U.S. elections and on the Rez.
They are newly elected. The work of governing takes time. My hope is not in immediate outcomes but in the opening their presence creates.
I am especially interested in what these newly elected Native American women will bring forward. I’m waiting to see what their leadership, priorities, and relationships with their communities make possible.
Their communities carry knowledge, histories, governance practices, and relationships that have shaped collective life across generations. I am interested in the possibilities that emerge when these understandings and experiences have greater opportunities to inform public decision-making. Specific practices within those communities are not my story to tell. What I can speak to is the significance of expanded presence and the questions it raises for the institutions they enter.
Some important areas of focus have emerged in the campaign discussions I’ve been following:
- Family – Affordability is a major concern. How do families meet their needs and care for one another when the costs of everyday living keep rising? What economic arrangements help families and generations support one another?
- Community – Childcare, healthcare, elder care, jobs, and the economy. How do we support the well-being of whole communities? What relationships and shared responsibilities sustain community life?
- Environment – First and foremost, Water Protectors insisting on no new data centers. Also, how do we live with climate chaos and respond to the mass extinction event underway? What does it mean to make decisions with Water, Land, and other living beings in mind?
- Equity – Dismantling corporate domination of people and planet. How might wealth, resources, and decision-making power be organized to support collective well-being?
These concerns reach beyond individual policy proposals. They raise questions about whose well-being matters, who participates in decisions, how resources are distributed, and what responsibilities we have to one another and to the living world.
They also point toward possibilities already taking shape in communities: people caring for children and elders, sharing resources, protecting water, sustaining local economies, and exercising collective responsibility.
This election offers hope because it may represent an opening for different ways of organizing our collective lives, grounded in community care.
- From accumulation toward collective well-being.
- From ownership toward relationship and responsibility.
- From competition toward cooperation.
- From centralized authority toward community participation and sovereignty.
- From treating Land, Water, and plant and animal life as resources toward recognizing reciprocal relationships with living beings and living systems.
There is an important distinction between community care as a policy objective and community care as an organizing principle.
As a policy objective, community care might mean providing childcare, healthcare, elder care, and environmental protections within existing political and economic arrangements.
As an organizing principle, community care reaches further. It influences how responsibilities are understood, how decisions are made, how resources circulate, and how power is distributed. It asks how communities sustain their own capacities to care for one another, how relationships with Land, Water, Plant and Animal kin inform decisions, and how different communities exercise sovereignty while respecting one another.
The question I am posing is: What understandings of relationship and responsibility organize the institutions through which collective life is governed?
Over time, different ways of relating and organizing can begin to change the very systems that shape our lives.
I have cautious hope because worldview carries embodied consequences involving institutional power.
I am hoping that a necessary worldview shift may be underway.
From power legitimized through law and exercised as domination:
Individualism, rights, hierarchy, ownership, control, exclusion, extraction, accumulation, concentration, conflict.
Toward legitimate power expressed through solidarity and collective consent:
Relationality, responsibilities, sovereignty, relationships, cooperation, presence, stewardship, sharing, distribution, peace.
To be clear, collective consent is not the same as majority rule.
A community can make decisions through dialog within circle processes, reciprocal responsibilities, deliberation, relationships with ancestors and future generations, and respect for the sovereignty of other communities.
This requires recognizing responsibilities that extend beyond individual interests and corporate profits. Decisions affect relationships among human and more-than-human beings, with consequences that extend across communities, ecosystems, and generations. It also means recognizing that sovereignty and self-determination matter. Communities must have a meaningful voice in decisions affecting their own lives, lands, and futures.
There is much work ahead. An election cannot, by itself, undo generations of institutional arrangements, concentrated wealth, or inherited assumptions about who gets to exercise power.
Openings matter.
Expanded voice matters.
Indigenous women and their communities have long histories of creating and transforming governance systems grounded in relational responsibility. Those practices and understandings have continued across generations, even while dominant institutions marginalized or ignored them. What is new is the increased formal presence of some of those women inside institutions that currently hold concentrated decision-making power.
Community care offers one way to ask what those existing relational understandings might begin to influence from within those institutions.
Power is often understood as the capacity to control others. Power can also be understood as the capacity to participate in creating and sustaining life in abundance. The capacity exists; the conditions for exercising it are also part of what is at stake. Institutional arrangements influence whether those capacities can be exercised, recognized, supported, and brought into public decision-making.
The work of governing takes time. The opening is here. What becomes of it remains an open question.
Author note: This article was written with iterative AI assistance.



The Scream